AI Search vs Google: How Discovery is Changing

    Understanding the fundamental differences between traditional search engines and AI assistants—and why your business needs to adapt.

    Alex Rapier

    AI Visibility Consultant · 10+ years in tech

    December 20247 min read

    For two decades, Google has been the gatekeeper of online discovery. But a fundamental shift is underway. AI assistants like ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini are changing how people find businesses, products, and services. Understanding this shift is crucial for any business that depends on being discovered online.

    The Google Model: Lists and Links

    Google's approach is fundamentally about options. You search, you get a list of ten results (plus ads), and you choose. The power is in your hands to click through, compare, and decide.

    This model created an entire industry around SEO—the art and science of getting your website to appear higher in those results. Keywords, backlinks, page speed, mobile-friendliness—businesses have spent billions optimising for Google's algorithm.

    The AI Model: Answers and Recommendations

    AI assistants work differently. They don't show you options—they give you answers. When you ask ChatGPT "What's the best CRM for a small marketing agency?", it doesn't show you ten blue links. It recommends one, maybe two or three, with explanations of why.

    The Fundamental Difference:

    • Google: "Here are your options, you decide"
    • AI: "Based on what you need, I recommend this"

    This shift from options to recommendations changes everything. In the Google model, being on page one among ten results was valuable. In the AI model, if you're not the recommendation, you're invisible.

    How Each Decides What to Show

    Google's Algorithm

    Google uses hundreds of ranking factors, but the core principles are:

    • Relevance: Does this page match what the user searched for?
    • Authority: Do other credible sites link to this page?
    • Experience: Is this page fast, mobile-friendly, and easy to use?
    • Freshness: Is the content up-to-date?

    AI's Decision-Making

    AI assistants synthesise information differently:

    • Reputation: What do reviews, articles, and discussions say about this business?
    • Clarity: Is it clear what this business does and who it serves?
    • Authority: Is this business recognised as a leader in its space?
    • Context: Does this business match what the user specifically needs?

    What This Means for Your Business

    1. Reputation Matters More Than Rankings

    In Google, you could rank well with good SEO even if you weren't the best option. AI is more discerning—it's trying to recommend the right choice, not just any choice that matches keywords.

    2. Clarity Beats Cleverness

    Clever marketing copy that works for humans might confuse AI. Being clear and specific about what you do, who you serve, and what makes you different is more important than ever.

    3. The Whole Internet is Your Profile

    AI doesn't just look at your website—it synthesises information from reviews, articles, social media, and discussions across the web. Your reputation everywhere matters.

    4. Winner-Takes-Most

    Google's ten results meant ten businesses got visibility. AI's one or two recommendations mean most competitors get nothing. The stakes are higher.

    Should You Abandon SEO?

    Absolutely not. Google still drives enormous traffic, and traditional SEO remains valuable. But smart businesses are now optimising for both:

    • Continue your SEO efforts for Google visibility
    • Build your reputation across the web for AI visibility
    • Create clear, specific content that both Google and AI can understand
    • Monitor how AI assistants perceive your business

    Not sure where you stand with AI?

    Our AI Visibility Audit shows you exactly how ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity see your business—and what to do about it.

    Get your AI visibility audit →

    The Future is Both

    We're not in an either/or world—we're in a both/and world. Google isn't going away, and AI search is only growing. The businesses that thrive will be those that understand both systems and optimise for visibility in each.

    The good news is that many AI visibility strategies—building authority, creating clear content, earning positive reviews—also help with traditional SEO. By focusing on genuinely being the best choice for your customers, you improve your visibility everywhere.

    Ready to improve your AI visibility?

    Get a comprehensive audit of how AI assistants see your business, with actionable recommendations to get found.

    Check Your AI Visibility